by Amanda Gayle
coming October 6, 2026
(4.5 / 5)

In Once, Again, Always we meet Molly, who has lost her memories from the past 6 years and is horrified to discover that she’s married to her old high school nemesis. It’s not surprising that this one turned out to be a pretty emotional read. It really captured Molly’s grief over her amnesia and how disorienting it could be. I also felt for Aster, who was in such a difficult situation as the spouse. But amidst the sad undertone, I also felt like there was a feeling of hope. I really enjoyed watching Molly and Aster reconnect, and the romance felt natural. I also liked the found family that Molly gained through some unexpected friends. Between the chapters, we get some brief “before” flashbacks to Molly’s time in high school and college. Aster was not likable at all during that time, but it also makes sense given Molly’s opinion of him in the beginning. It’s almost hard to believe that a person could change so much, but not enough that it took away from my enjoyment of the story. This book was mostly about the characters’ journeys, though there’s still some drama worked in. I’m impressed with how drawn in and invested I was with this story. What a great debut novel, I look forward to seeing more from the author!
Thank you to Avon and NetGalley for providing a free review copy of this book! All thoughts and opinions in my review are completely my own.

(4 / 5)






(3 / 5)





















